Accountability Without Overreach: Why the CRL Commission Risks Undermining Religious Freedom By Fr Mathibela Sebothoma The failure of parts of the Church to govern itself responsibly is no longer in dispute. Financial misconduct, abuse of authority, and weak internal accountability have rightly provoked public anger. These failures demand consequences. But they do not justify a solution that threatens a core constitutional freedom. In its growing intervention into religious life, the Cultural, Religious and Linguistic (CRL) Rights Commission risks crossing an important line: from protecting citizens against abuse to policing belief itself. A constitutional democracy must be able to hold religious institutions accountable without deciding what counts as a “legitimate” religion or how faith should be practised. When the state assumes that role, freedom of religion becomes conditional—granted only to those who pass official approval. To be clear, churches are not above the...